Letters of Recommendation

This entry from 2023 is SOOOO good it deserves a re-issue – enjoy..

.Letters of RecomemDamnation       

I found it. Amidst the rapidly resolving rummaged clutter of the basement, it was one piece of paper. But that one piece of paper  –  what secrets it holds. I’ve tried to remember some over the years and probably succeeded. I was surprised to see there are 6. Here’s the background:

During my career as a Corporate Guy, I had many occasions to hire people to help me. I didn’t exactly enjoy the experience, but I was quick to recognize that if I hired a hard-working person, I could be doing something else. This is one of the hidden secrets of Company Living. If you can get others to do your job, it’s a good thing. Think of it as the Tom Sawyer approach to Management.

No one is perfect and the hiring process occasionally fails, and a hard-working person turns happiness sucking vampire and must be mercilessly fired ASAP. The latter action is always hampered by jackals in Human Resources whose Rules & Procedures slow all progress to a near stand-still.

You do the “Hire/Fire” routine a bunch of times and you develop a healthy respect for the process of finding good people. They are not hard to spot. You keep in touch and look for opportunities to move them along either in your own group or some other area. Conversely, the “not so good” people need to be encouraged to move alone also. In their case, hopefully to competitor companies.

Finally, we get to the meat of this Blog:

These six seemingly innocent sentences successfully cloak the truth with clever bromides of verbal legerdemain.

I love them

How to Write a Recommendation Letter That You Don’t Really Mean (examples)

  1.  (to describe a person who is extremely lazy)  “In my opinion, you will be very fortunate to get this person to work for you.”
  2. (to describe a person who is totally inept) “I most enthusiastically recommend this candidate with no qualifications whatsoever” or “When you give this candidate a project, you can just forget about it.”
  3. (to describe an ex-employee who had trouble getting along with others) “I am pleased to say that this candidate is a former colleague of mine.”
  4. (to describe a person who is so unproductive that the job would be better off unfilled) “I can assure you that no person would be better for the job.”
  5. To describe a job applicant who is not worth further consideration) “ I would urge you to waste no time in making this candidate an offer of employment.”
  6. (to describe a person with lackluster credentials) “All in all, I cannot say enough good things about this candidate or recommend him too highly

Ode to the Salesman

It has been said that salesmen are big problems to their bosses, their customers, and their wives, to conservative managers, to hotels and sometimes to each other. Individually and collectively they are cursed and discussed in sales meetings, conventions, behind closed doors, in barrooms and under one’s breath from as many angles and with about the same fervor as the daily headlines.

They make more noise and mistakes, create more cheer, correct more errors, adjust more differences, spread more gossip, hear more grievances, pacify more belligerents and waste more time under high pressure without losing their tempers than any class we know including ministers. They live in hotels, cabs, in tents, on trains, buses and park benches, eat all kinds of food, drink all kinds of liquids, good and bad, sleep before, during and after business with no more schedule than the weather.

And yet salesmen are a power in society and in the public economy. They spend more money with less effort than any other group in business. They come at the most inopportune time under the slightest pretext, stay longer under more opposition, ask more personal questions, make more comments put up with more inconveniences, take more for granted under greater resistance, than any group including the U.S. Army.

They introduce more goods, dispose of more old goods, load more freight cars, unload more ships, build more factories, start more new business, and write more debits and credits than all other people in America.

Yes, brother, you said it. With all their faults, they keep the wheels of commerce turning and the currents of human emotions running. More cannot be said of anyone. So be careful whom you call SALESMAN, lest you flatter him or her.

My First (and last) Golf Outing

In my Corporate career, I worked in Finance, Sales, Marketing, IT and Supply Management (we used to call it Purchasing!). I spent the longest time in Sales. I still consider myself a Salesman (see Ode to a Salesman). I had many many opportunities to Golf. Sales people always golf; it is a prime time to schmoose a customer. I never did it. I’d beg off. If I was at a three day sales meeting there would be two days of meeting and the third day was a Golf Outing with an awards dinner and all kinds of golf related stuff like “Closest to the pin” and “Mulligan Award” handed out with applause and booze all around. I would leave the night before or the morning of and be at work working while my fellows were golfing.

Until my last job in Supply Management. It was a three day meeting at the Marriott Seaview in New Jersey. The third day was a Golf Outing. At dinner the night before I said to my boss, “I’ll be leaving after breakfast and returning to work, anything you want me to take care of in the office?”. She replied, “You should join us for Golf – think of it as a bonding experience.” I said I don’t golf. She said you can drive the golf cart but you WILL join us tomorrow at 9AM.

I did. I drove a golf cart. I tried to follow the balls my fellow golfers were hitting, but could not for the life of me track those suckers. It was a lovely day. At the 8th hole we stopped at a little house structure that was filled with snacks and treats and refreshments of every kind. The young girl behind the counter said “What can I get you?” And she meant ANYTHING I wanted – for FREE!! I could not believe what was happening. And then Lunch happened – and went on and on until 2:45. Driving home after lunch (because it was too late to go to the office) I commiserated with myself. What a fool I had been all those years to pass up the Golf!

He’s Listening

Be Careful What you say with Children Around

I think my son was 10 – what’s that 3rd grade? Anyway, I was explaining to my lovely wife how as soon a John A had left his office with all his boxes on his way to a happy retirement, I was in MY boss’s office asking if I could move into John A’s corner office. “Sure”, he said, and I was gone!

Down in the Building Maintenance area, I met with Vinnie and picked out a small secretary desk. “You don’t want a big Executive Desk with Credenza ?” Vinnie asked. I explained I wanted my desk along one wall facing the windows. I want to see outside – not sit with my back to the windows. I got a circular table and put it in the middle of the room with NO chairs in front of my small desk. When someone came into my office, I’d get up and we would sit at the table and talk.

The view outside was woods and parking lot, but it was my view and I was proud of it and My lovely wife shared my feeling. My son was listening. Several days later, at dinner to the question “What happened at school, today”, he answered, “We had what does your Dad do today”.

I said I didn’t remember him asking me what I did. He replied, “I heard you tell Mom that you sit in your office and look out the windows so that’s what I told my class you do every day.” We had a good laugh and I agreed with him.

Uh-Oh the Helen Story

Upstairs at the Bicycle Club

is perfect for a retirement party, I thought, as I stepped to the podium. I waited what probably seemed a long time, but the anticipation from the crowd was so palpable I couldn’t help savoring the moment. “I am not here to roast Helen,” I began. “Helen would be best braised with aromatics for six to seven hours. Either way there’s just not enough time.” I searched the crowd of about sixty for my boss and my wife and nodded at both. “I want to mention to both my lovely wife and my boss that while I understand your concerns, I do not feel obligated to censure any portion of my presentation – THE TRUTH SHALL BE KNOWN.  However, due to the potentially explosive nature of some of my comments I have been advised by counsel to stick to a written script.” 

“I would like to summarize the results of research I conducted regarding Helen’s career with our Company. I will share some of the more salient observations and comments – some are good, some not so good. But as I know Helen would say – “WHO CARES!” Here are some of the terms that kept coming up: dedicated, hardworking, sense of humor, explosive, will beat the shit out of a problem. I know this one firsthand because on more than one occasion I was the problem. Helen started and managed the IT Help Desk for many years. I like to say Helen put the HEL in HELP.” 

I shot a few more barbed zingers and sat down to pleased and, from my boss, relieved applause. Helen’s current boss spoke briefly and then the party began. My lovely wife J had worked with Helen for many years and had been invited. I was making my way to her and Helen, drink in one hand, small dish of shrimp and mini quiche in the other. Suddenly Linda C. was in front of me; very much in front of me. One might say invading the private space in front of me. She reached up and began fixing my tie all the while bubbling about how she had had no idea what a wonderful speaker I was and so witty and confident. While she gushed, I watched my wife over her right shoulder watch us. Helen looked to J and to me and back to J. I gave my wife my best Johnny Carson innocent look and she started to laugh.  

I let Linda go on for just a little longer while a crowd formed behind her: my wife, Helen and a few friends who could see what was happening and wanted in on the climax. “Linda,” I asked with my best dead pan look, “have you met my lovely wife, J?” 

Adventures in Corporate World

Written in three parts during the period May – December 2005

The Early Years

I went to work for The Company in February 1972.  My good friend S found a Want Ad for an “adjusting clerk”. Ed hired me after his first choice flunked the company physical. Ed was a dictatorial, egotistical little skinny Italian who talked rapidly in a whisper unless he was pointing out your mistakes. Ed served as a model of the manager I vowed to never become. I have lunch with Ed occasionally. He’s mellowed over the years and is a doting Grandfather now. The irony being he never spent much time with his own three children except to tell them what to do.

My job as adjusting clerk ($620.00 per month) was to reconcile the differences between bills to customers and their payments. This required me to write “memos” to the Salesman involved to ask what’s up. As the only male doing this, I developed friendships with the salesmen “in the field”. We came to like each other. Within 9 months, Ed promoted me to Supervisor of the Adjusting Department. I made it a point to always explain to my staff why we were doing things, talk quietly and generally set a good example. Carbon paper was still used in the mid 70’s. Calculators were big and loud. Cubicles hadn’t been invented. There was no Dilbert.

By 1976, I was the Manager of Accounts Receivable & Warehouse Records. The Vice President of Sales asked to talk to me about a job opening. I went and was hired as the Manager of Sales Systems. There were no sales systems. My first assignment was to visit each of the 27 sales offices in the USA and document their “systems”. Then I was to standardize procedures across the country. Airports, hotels and travel in general quickly became mundane as I was away a week and home a week for almost a year.

After a big Sales reorganization, many of the Sales guys I used to write and help were promoted to management jobs – one in particular became the VP of Sales and my boss: Mike.  I used to hate people obviously sucking up to the boss by sitting in his office bullshitting. When Mike came , I would get his coffee and we’d sit every morning and bullshit – in his big office. I knew people were walking by saying “what a suckass” but I didn’t care. Mike taught me THE SECRET. Which really isn’t a secret – just well hidden in its obviousness. The secret is: the harder you work, the luckier you are. Mike was there when Personal Computers were born and allowed young K to buy several to play with. They were very cool.

Soon young K was berating the “Computer Department” for their lack of attention to an opportunity to improve sales effectiveness by investing in information reporting. I would periodically throw hand grenades into the Computer group – one guy, Bill, once threatened to punch me in the mouth.  With my boss’s support, I built a small group of Sales personnel whose mission was to “create an environment that encourages intelligent decision making”. Mike and I agreed that the purpose of a Headquarters Staff was to SUPPORT the field, not HINDER them with useless reports and Bullshit. Along this way I met a lovely young girl named J and fell in love.

In 1989, Mike was promoted to President of a division located in Chicago. Mike’s replacement was not Mike, which prompted me to accept a Special Assignment to develop a new “sales promotion analysis system”. I worked with one other guy for 500 days and we delivered. As a reward I was given the opportunity to work in the “Computer Department” for Bill and hire a group whose purpose would be to support the Sales and Marketing organizations. “I can do that”, I said, smiling to Bill, as he smiled back through clenched teeth.

Bill was the first real asshole I ever worked for. We tolerated one another because he was smart enough to realize you don’t kill the golden goose and I was having too much fun to care what he thought. A new Company President had been hired from the outside who looked around and said, “You people need some Sales & Marketing systems”. I was entering Fat City.

So what did K learn during the early years?

CORPORATE WORLD LESSON 1.  All assholes and egotistical dictatorial tactless Italians serve a purpose – even if it’s to be a bad example

 The Golden Years

So there I was entering Fat City. It’s 1991. The Vice President of Finance had called the Director of IT and said “Create a Department for K that involves Sales and Marketing information systems”. And Bill did what he was told and I found myself managing a small group of people who, independent of each other, had been evaluating a new tool that could deliver data to a person’s PC (remember this is 1991).  My new assistant arranged a demonstration of this tool. I watched, I asked questions, I watched again and as I felt my socks rolling down my ankles I said “Holy Shit. I sure hope this works”.

Well it didn’t and we spent months / years and millions of dollars getting it right – but we did. We allowed a salesman to see his accounts and their activity. We allowed a brand manager to see sales and promotion activities. All by 1998. And we had a great time doing it – at least I did and based on the lack of turnover and the avalanche of applications for new hires whenever we expanded, the whole group was having fun.

Of course, like any job, it had its share of what I call “stupid stuff”. One great irony of my job was finding myself in the same intimidating corner office into which I would regularly throw handgrenades when I was a young whippersnapper. Now I would spend my time ducking handgrenades thrown by even younger young whippersnappers. The good news is I could and often did explain the planning process and the best practices that allow a World-Class organization with minimal headquarters staff to maintain the optimum balance of productivity with fiscal efficiency. In short, I blew the upstarts off just as I’d been blown off.

In truth, I was always open to a good argument and could change on a dime to a better idea. Hell, all I did was interpret my boss’s (or if he was an asshole – HIS boss’s) goals. Then I’d sell my staff on individual goals that if accomplished would more that satisfy my boss’s goals. All I had to do was whatever was necessary to allow my staff to succeed. This occasionally meant I was called to a meeting to give THE LOOK or (on a rare, lucky day) to go absolutely ballistic and yell and scream or something that would accomplish the same result – a project back on track.

Were we successful in creating an environment that encouraged intelligent decision making? Yes. Unfortunately, our success and the general success of the entire organization brought The Company to the attention of, a European giant 6 times our size who said in 1999 “we will pay you bunches of money because we admire you and need the passion and excellence of your management team” (are you smelling the bullshit?). It was a bitter / sweet time when “We” were sold to “Them”. On the one hand, everyone holding The Company’s stock (which was pretty much EVERY Employee) was receiving a 40% appreciation INSTANTLY. On the other hand, our family of friends was about to be swallowed by a company ruled by Bean-Counters. On the day the sale was completed, my old friend Mike had a stoke and died (no shit!).

CORPORATE WORLD LESSON 2.  Nothing ever works right. Most people couldn’t find happiness with a lantern and a hound dog. Accept these truths and know that laughter keeps the demons away.

The Quickening

By “quickening” I mean the feeling that something is out of balance and some great change is about to happen; that life as we know it is about to change.

“They” paid 25 Billion dollars for “Us”. Originally billed as a “merger of equals” it quickly became apparent who was on top. I was one of 7 Directors of IT “Us” who spent 3 weeks with 9 Directors of IT (Them) building a new organization that would include the “Best of the Best”. While we were waxing eloquent in a conference room, the VP’s of IT were deciding which Systems were redundant and therefore doomed. Unfortunately, the wonderful information systems my team had spent years building were deemed “too expensive and not compatible with existing “Them” Systems.”

The music had stopped and there wasn’t a chair for me in IT. My boss (no, not Bill – he was gone) told me I could stay on as his assistant until I found a job in the merged Company. Half my staff took jobs with the new organization, half were asked or chose to leave. Terms of leaving were very attractive (like 2 1/2 years pay if you promised not to sue) but nevertheless these were dark times. Especially since the systems we were abandoning were far far superior to “Their” alternatives. I bid sad farewells to many wonderful people.

It took three months for me to find a place. The VP of Supply Management, an “Us” person who was systems savvy, offered me a newly created job as Director of Purchasing Systems. I asked why she wanted a person with zero purchasing experience and she replied: “I’ve seen what you did for Sales and Marketing and I want you to do the same for Purchasing”. I smiled and said, “I can do that”.

And so I found myself once again hiring a staff, making plans and gaining an understanding of what makes purchasing work and how I could contribute to “creating an environment that encourages intelligent decision making” (sound familiar?). Of course, I had to work with “Their” mandated technologies – and I found myself suddenly in a Global environment. My old Company was a worldwide company but each country ruled their own area relatively independently. The new guys, on the other hand, were very interested in developing Global answers to problems.

I often flew to Europe to represent the USA Purchasing group as part of a global initiative to provide intelligence to purchasing agents. Seven people formed a core group and we had some interesting times. I discovered what the “Dutch Consensus Model” is at one of our earlier meetings. I was arguing some point when Jose, the team leader, said to me “K, we use the Dutch Consensus Model for these discussions” I asked what that is. Jose replied; “ If we don’t all agree to a certain plan, then we cannot recommend to our management any course of action”. I explained to Jose the USA Consensus Model – “we go into a room, we yell and scream, we bang fists on the table and get red in the face: but at the end of the day, we go with the majority view (or the boss’s view)”. Jose replied that’s not the “Our”Way. I’m proud to report I said; “now I know why the Dutch have never become a World Power”. The silence was deafening.

Meanwhile, back in the USA, we were making good progress delivering information to purchasing agents. . For example, within a year we’d reduced the number of different types / sizes / formulas of salt from 45 to 12.  Some people in the IT Department were old  friends so getting things done was easier for my group. Unfortunately, the European methods of management were taking their toll on those old friends. We were used to working for results. Our “New” counterparts were used to working for promotions – there is a BIG difference. More and more old friends fell away. Not me, I was still having fun and keeping a good attitude.

Not so with my boss who resigned in July 2004. Her replacement was a “Them”  veteran who arrived in September. We had our first face to face meeting in October. My new boss asked if I knew that one of my brother Purchasing Directors was not using the information reports my group provided. I replied that I could “care less” that “you can lead a horse to water…”etc. The silence was deafening. Two weeks later my position was eliminated. It was fun while it lasted. I was given the opportunity to “retire” or be “fired”. I did NOT retire. I took my perks and bunch of cash and rode quietly into the night. My group still exists (although my Number One now works for another company in Ohio).The sun still came up the day after I left.

CORPORATE WORLD LESSON 3.   Americans are unique in our ability to cut to the chase and alienate many other cultures with our fuck you attitude. If you are young and looking to get ahead, it’s best to temper this uniqueness with humility. I never could. I’m pleased to say my son can and does. He is so much better than his father!

 

Flying in the Old Days

“Oh no” I gasped, quickly checking my left back pants pocket – empty. My wallet was in my car cup holder. I had taken it out to get a dollar for the 70 cent toll on the Newark Airport exit of the Turnpike. Fumbling with the toll receipt and my seatbelt I’d put the wallet in the cup holder. I was currently seated on a 6:05AM flight to Dallas. Let’s see, I mentally calculated, I had 15 minutes; I was parked in the Hourly Section right outside the baggage claim area. The gate wasn’t that far down the Concourse. I could probably run out and be back in 12 minutes. It wasn’t worth the chance I concluded. I didn’t really need a wallet or money for this trip. 

I was on a day trip to the Dallas Sales office to train a group of sales reps in a new tracking program. B, the office manager, would pick me up at Dallas / Fort Worth Airport drive me to the office, lunch would be brought in and B would drive me back for a 5:45PM flight to Newark. I had my return ticket and no need for ID, money or credit cards. I wouldn’t be able to buy a $2.50 cocktail (or 2 little bottles for $5.00) on the flight home – no big deal. 

The flight landed on time. B was waiting at the gate. The day went as planned and B drove me back. Dallas / Fort Worth Airport posted the gate numbers for current flights on huge lighted billboards on the approach roads, allowing drop off right outside the appropriate gate. I arrived 15 minutes early and was quickly aboard. B had gotten a kick out of my destitute status and loaned me $5.00.  As I sipped my large Vodka and orange juice, I was oblivious to the changes that would soon take place with regard to the experience of flying. What a difference!!